God is a circle whose centre is everywhere and circumference nowhere.
- Timaeus of Locris
**
You cannot be
too gentle, too kind. Shun even to appear harsh in your treatment of
each other. Joy, radiant joy, streams from the face of one who gives
and kindles joy in the heart of one who receives.
- St. Seraphim of Sarov
**
(The
following is transcripted from my imperfect notes taken this past
weekend. The talk was by Roberta Bondi, taken from her books on the
desert Abbas and Ammas; "To Pray and to Love" "To Love As God Loves"
and "Memories of God".)
Roberta Bondi Talk
Retreat July 26, 2008
Cherry Log, Ga.
It's interesting to ask: What the desert fathers (and mothers) thought they were doing?
They
were fulfilling Jesus' command to Love God with their whole heart and
their neighbors as themselves. Everything was measured by love -- love
of God and love of neighbor.
This is the 4th or 5th century.
In
the 6th century, we find Dortheus. The favorite activity of the monks
was fighting with one another. There are accounts of Monks peeing on
the heads of other monks -- you name it. He has many "Why you
shouldn't fight with your brothers" sermons. The normal response
would be something like: " I could just love God if I didn't have to
put up with these horrible people."
Think
of a circle you draw with a compass. God is at the center . People
and the world and all in it are all around. Draw a line from God to
world, world to God , and the closer you get to the center (to God)
the closer you get to other people. You can't love God and not love
other people. Moving towards God doesn't move you apart from other
people. It's a piece of information about reality --- about the
direction you're going. How can I tell when I'm making up God? Or
when it's really God and not something else? ["Oh, I can't know
about all the horrible things in the world....."] This drawing,
this metaphor aids discernment.
FEARFUL BELIEFS IN OUR VERY BODIES
The
starting point of the Christian life is love of God and love of
neighbor. They had no illusion -- that you suddenly woke up one morning
and loved God and your neighbor. We have to learn to do it. We have
to move on that path of love in our lifetime.
"How can I learn to love _____?"
Be considerate of him. Have sympathy. Have mercy. Help him out. Regard the well being of the person as your own.
Break
it down into tiny little steps. It wasn't laid out in advance. It's
not paint-by-numbers. It wasn't predetermined. Break down the job.
Learning
to love is a long process. The hypocrisy of Christians can be the
pretense of it being a done deal. Pretended knowingness and pretended
insight..... It comes from needing to act as though we are already
there, which again, creates a lie and a false self that leads us away
from love of God and love of neighbor. It's much deeper and harder
than that. The humility demanded knows that this task takes our entire
life. So it is futile to pretend to be at the end of a path that has
only just begun. You can't love the person you don't know. Which
includes yourself.
We have inside of us,
fearsome abusive images of God. How does God (that God) love us?
If the interest that God has in us is primarily critical, how do we
internalize that relationship? The images of hell, criticism, lack
of love, lack of acceptance, guilt and failure stand between us and
the love of God.
The emphasis on 'belief in
______" (virgin births , aspects of creedal and dogmatic life) without
curiosity was not the way of the desert fathers. We cannot exclude our
own curiosity. "If I had loved that God -- that would have destroyed
me." It's not just a 'head' image, but what is true in every pore of
your body.
HEROIC MEASURE TO 'FIX' WHAT IS 'WRONG'
What
about God do we have wrong? It is that aspect that we have wrong that ruins us. Our life's work is
investigating that which is "the good news." We think we have it right, but it's always under investigation. The warning is against
our own tendency to want to take heroic measures to fix that which is
'wrong'. We have to understand that seeing it changes it. In the
21st century, we say "work harder work harder aim higher aim
higher". The desert culture says, "back off."
So,
if you're trying to set up a prayer discipline, set up 1/2 as much as
you think you can do. Cut that in half. Make it so that you can
actually DO it so you don't get discouraged and quit. See the long
view, the change over time. It's not just the prayer.
Anthony, one of the first of the monks , dating from the 5th century:
[from "Sayings of the Desert Fathers" trans. Benedicta Ward]
"When the holy Abba Anthony lived in the desert he was beset by accidie,
and attacked by many sinful thoughts. He said to God, "Lord, I want to
be saved but these thoughts do not leave me alone; what shall I do in
my affliction? How can I be saved? A short while afterwards, when he
got up to go out, Anthony saw a man like himself sitting at his work,
getting up from his work to pray, then sitting down and plaiting a
rope, then getting up again to pray. It was the angel of the Lord
sent to correct and reassure him. He heard the angel saying to him,
"Do this and you will be saved." At these words, Anthony was filled
with joy and courage. He did this, and he was saved."
Our
desire in the spiritual life is to be heroic -- get get where we're
going. To have arrived. All the people to love -- how hard that is!
It's somehow easier to live within the fantasy of the great deed,
being somehow a superbeing, being valiant. We ask ourselves, "What am I
going to do?" and look around for some great purpose or great deed to
hurl ourselves towards. The desert teachers point our gaze back to
the ordinary things of one's life. Making rope and standing up and
praying. Nothing is heroic about this world. The "big stuff" is what
tends to get us in trouble.
ABOUT BEING UNABLE TO KEEP UP WITH MY PRAYERS
Prayer
About
prayer itself they had little to say; the life geared towards God was
the prayer; and about contemplation, who could speak? Arsenius
prayed on Saturday evening with his hands stretched out to the setting
sun, and he stayed there until the sun shone on his face on Sunday.
The usual pattern was to say the Psalms, one after another, during
the week, and to intersperse this with weaving ropes, sometimes
saying, 'Lord Jesus Christ, have mercy upon me.' The aim was hesychia,
quiet, the calm through the whole man that is like a still pool of
water, capable of reflecting the sun. To be in true relationship with
God, standing before him in every situation -- that was the angelic
life, the spiritual life, the monastic life, the aim and the way of
the monk. It was life orientated towards God. 'Unless a man can say,
"I alone and God are here", he will not find the prayer of quiet.' It
is the other side of the saying of St. Anthony, "My life is with my
brother.'
[The Sayings of the Desert Fathers trans. by Benedicta Ward, SLG]
**
"It
is helpful to understand that regularity is more sustaining in prayer
than intensity or length. You are spending time with God, learning
who God is and who you are, learning to love God and God's world, and
this happens over a matter of years. If you miss some days, start
again, and think small. A brother told an Abba that he had gotten away
from his monastic disciplines, presumably including his prayer, and he
felt too discouraged to begin again. The Abba replied by telling him
this story:
" A man had a plot of land.
And through his carelessness brambles sprang up and it became a
wilderness of thistles and thorns. Then he decided to cultivate it. So
he said to his son: 'Go and clear that ground.' So the son went to
clear it, and saw that the thistles and thorns had multiplied......
He said: 'How much time shall I need to clear and weed all this?' And
he lay down on the ground and went to sleep. He did this day after
day. Later his father cam to see what he had done, and found him
doing nothing."
When his father asked him
about it, the son replied that the job looked so bad that he could
never make himself begin. His father replied,
"'Son,
if you had cleared each day the area on which you lay down, your work
would have advanced slowly and you would not have lost heart.' So the
lad did what his father said, and in a short time the plot was
cultivated."
So the Abba told the discouraged brother,
"Do a little work and do not faint, and God will give you grace."
The
disheartened brother took up his prayer again with patience without
trying to do everything. You can, too. Prayer is for you. Prayer is
not a test of your character, and endurance contest, or a heroic task
set before you.
**
Heroic doesn't work.
That
thinking tells us lies. It makes up false Gods, like the God who
hates us. The belief in a hateful God is different from not believing
in God. It's hard to let go of these ideas and feelings. The world is
made is a way that makes us long for God, for the love of God. It is
the love of God that holds us all in existence. No matter what bad or
destructive notions we have, we're made to want/desire "the real
thing." We seek what is genuine. We love and don't love at the same
time. But that which is of God, which is the truth , will help
us to seek our way. We are learning to recognize and to know what we
are. We are gaining the insight to know what is in us intrinsically.
The
thought or the inner belief that God hates us is a terrible wound, a
hurt. It is as though we are a child watching our parents drive off
saying "we're never coming back." In the book of Genesis, God saw it
(creation) was "very very good." The goodness of reality confirms for
us that God was good in that particular way. That the world was
lovable. We can see in the world 'the beauty of God,' this God of
Creation.
In the midst of this sorting out, we can begin to want the scary heroic part for ourselves.
The
center part of the world's pie is for God. If something else gets put
there, it'll make you miserable. That's not the place for that. No
person, thing, concern or object will fit in the place , for that is God's
place. If we persist in placing something or someone inappropriate in
that place, it will not work and we will grow more and more let
down. They simply cannot fill that place. If we persist in forcing
the issue , it is to the detriment of all concerned. Our attachments
are a sort of idol. They are not wicked. They just make us miserable.
Even
if "I don't trust God" , I trust these teachers, these desert
people. They won't lie to me and they love me, even it they're
wrong. (Abbas and Ammas) It's our ancestors, our grandparents. We
trust the integrity of their vision, of how they lived and died.
Their lessons and teachings are still valid for us. They are
trustworthy. We can keep reading them, stay in the relationship and
learn from it.
Dogma and belief, i.e.,
that 'Jesus Christ is the Son of God' etc. was not terribly important
to the desert teachers. Their view was that we are made in a way that
we're drawn to God. That 'Christian' was not the only way to do it. That relationship, that search was senior in importance to dogma
or what one believed. The search involved the longing of one's
entire being, not just our head. It's not our convictions that save
us (so to speak)....
Even the words 'Save
Us' referred to what will continue to bring us to God. It involved a
way of being and thriving in spite of what else is going on in life and
the world not just 'fire insurance.' Scripture and how it looks brings
the recognition that kindness and love are what brings us to the Throne
of God. Kindness and love reveal the love of God and allow us to pass
on this 'saving' this salvation, this grace.
The
idea that one "can't believe the wrong things" can also be a dangerous
fallacy. The view that God's righteousness is primary, that there is
a knife edge about right and wrong can bring about in a person or a
community a position of exclusion and legalism. The primary
characteristic of God is ______, --- if it is the wrong thing here,
that idea will lead you to hurt and exclude people from the love of God.
If
you are Christian and trinitarian, the reading of that dogma can become
destructive religion if God is on top, Jesus is subordinate and the Holy Spirit is flying around somewhere...... The religious arc that
portrays Jesus as effeminate and weak is headed towards the religion
that enforces "females obey males." Church doctrine includes the idea
that the three of the trinity are equal. This makes a fundamental
difference.
We give ourselves reason to
believe ourselves to be inferior. It doesn't matter what we believe.
We can be terrorized by what we believe. We can hurt people with those
beliefs.
In the early church, they were
still figuring it out. We're still figuring it out. As Origen says,
God comes to each of us according to our need.
Any Christian doctrine that breaks our spirit and demoralizes us is false. God isn't about crushing us.
"Our
mother -- our father" : God comes to us according to our need. God is
that presence there for you. We thrive as a result of that prayer.
God is that presence that nourishes and nurtures us.
Love is foundational. It is the basic principal . That which destroys love is for us to avoid.
There
is a need for gentleness with ourselves, rather than bullying and
'controlling' ourselves. We drive ourselves away from God. We speak
harshly to ourselves. We alienate ourselves from God in this habitual
degradation of our godliness. When our interaction with either
someone else or ourself is dominated by control and trying to make
guilty, when we bully ourselves with these tactics, we just want to
get away.
We commit to the discipline,
not to use language to ourselves that cuts us down. It is the picture
of mercy and kindness of the Ammas and Abbas that counters the picture
idea or image of God /Self/ other as adversary.
It's
so easy to fall into the trap. Few people have too high an opinion of
themselves. God isn't interested in either our perfection or our
sin. Then we can lose the need to be heroic.
We
will be saved. We will be preserved in our seeking of God. We will
find what it is to fulfill our own nature. We will find that which
keeps us in life and lets us die in trust. We don't need to know
beyond that point.
**
Cross-posted to Alive on All Channels
**